So, I've listed the shows I follow regularly, by genre, and the ones in bold are the new shows that have caught my eye, and I approve of them for now.
Comedy
Better Off Ted*The IT Crowd
Action
NCISCovert Affairs
The Mentalist
Lie To Me
Psych
White Collar
Trauma*
Knight Rider*
Sci-Fi
Doctor WhoEleventh Hour*
Fringe
Sanctuary
Haven
Mind-blowing
Criminal MindsMusic
GleeAs you can see nothing can replace or even complement Criminal Minds. It's like people saying Salt can complement Inception. Like hello?! She's totally out of my league.
Anyway, those with asterisks means they've axed future episodes, sadly.
P.s. If you want any of these shows, just ask. :)